HR role: strategic versus employee advocate?
1314
Dear Joan:
I am currently in my final year of my degree in Human Resource Management and strategy at the Australian National University, Canberra. I am undertaking tutorial programs for first and second year students and have come across an interesting query that through a lot of reading I am still unsure on how I should attack the problem.
The question posed to me in a nutshell was “Can HR professionals be both strategic business partners as well as employee advocates?” My initial response is, “Yes,” however I have researched Ulrich and Brockbanks work and am still unsure with the ever changing HR industry whether it is the correct direction that it is headed. Any insights to this topic will be extremely helpful. Thank you.
Answer:
This is a timely question, since the HR profession is evolving to become more strategic. It began as more of a clerical function, managing benefits and payroll. As company’s needs changed, it became the “Personnel Department,” where employees were hired, fired, tested and sometimes trained. Unfortunately, the function sometimes earned the reputation of the “people police.”
As companies have become more sophisticated, the function has moved into a more strategic role. In these companies, the leader of the HR function reports to the leader of the organization and is a part of the senior management team. He or she is a key participant in discussions about changes in operations, acquisitions, employee communications, management performance, and any other key topic where people are impacted.
At the same time, the HR executive has a staff that works with all levels of the organization—some are in a very tactical role and others may be in more of a business partner role. For this reason, many HR organizations have a structure that is split. For example, recruiting, salary and benefits and training are areas that require a high degree of specialization. In a large company, you will often see specialized units such as a recruiting team, a salary and benefits team, and so on.
Along with those specialty teams, there is a new HR role emerging. It is sometimes called the “HR business consultant” or “HR business partner.” These generalists are each assigned to a business group, such as a manufacturing plant. Usually they report to the HR department, with a “dotted line” reporting relationship to the operations leader they serve. This reporting relationship assures that HR services are consistent across the company, and yet the business unit gets one point of contact who can tap others in the HR department, as needed.
The internal HR business partner acts as a key member of the business unit’s leadership team. In the case of the HR generalist who serves a plant, he or she would attend the plant manager’s staff meetings; work with all the plant managers, and also with the employees of the plant.
The answer to your question about whether HR should be strategic or employee advocates is not black and white. I think the modern HR department—regardless of each person’s particular job—needs to be focused on the wellbeing of the overall organization. They must think like “owners” of the business. As an example, in the past a recruiter would fill a job. Today, a recruiter needs to step back and consider the bigger picture: can the duties be done without filling the job? Is the job description appropriate, given the future needs of the business? Are the candidates the right fit for the culture?
Even the “Employee Relations Specialist” needs to balance every intervention with what’s right for the organization. Only advocating for employees would be a mistake. The modern employee relations professional must consider the three legs of the stool for a balanced decision—the employee, the manager, the organization.
So the answer to your question is that any successful person in HR today needs to consider many things when taking any action--business strategy, a healthy culture that creates a win/win environment, the bottom line results, as well as the needs of all employees at all levels. This list is the same list that keeps any good leader up at night.
============================================
Register now for Internal Consulting Skills for Human Resource Professionals
========================================
Facilitated by Joan Lloyd, on June 10, 2009
This full-day training lab is perfect for HR professionals who want to move beyond administrative and tactical duties and add value as an internal consultant in their organization.
Human resources professionals—both functional experts and generalists—are finding new opportunity to act as internal consultants who can help their organizations with organizational changes, performance coaching, conflict mediation and other value-added services. We give HR professionals the tools and strategies they need to help their organizations as well as advance their careers.
You will have an opportunity to work on the problems and opportunities you face in your own organization, as well as to diagnose and strategize with other professionals. Each participant will receive detailed, personal feedback and coaching.
Are you interested, or are there other HR professionals in your organization who would benefit from participating in this intensive, interactive small group workshop? We will accept a maximum of 15 registrations per session, so each of our registrants gets lots of individual attention. Few training opportunities provide this level of intimate, hands-on experience.
You will learn:
- What an Internal Consultant does and how it is different from the way you work now.
- New consulting competencies—practice the core skills.
- Establishing your new role with your clients.
- Identify your “internal market” and assess—and build--your influence and credibility.
- How to do value-added work by turning the wrong work into the right solution.
- How to contract with your internal clients so there are no surprises later.
- How to give honest feedback to senior executives / managers / employees.
- How to deal with resistant, internal clients.
- How to become a sought after performance coach—intake contracting, behavioral coaching, gathering 360 data, working with the internal client’s manager.
- How to deal with the political realities and find ways around roadblocks when implementing change.
Comments from prior workshop participants:
"I now understand how important it is to ask the right questions to get the other individual to discover, on their own, what the real issue is. I learned techniques for pushing back, and asking more questions. I’ll find it easier now to do what needs to be done, not just what other people tell me to do. I will definitely recommend this lab to others, it was well worth my time.”
"I found the small group setting to be helpful. It made the lab personable and made it easy to ask my questions and really participate. You were flexible, knowledgeable and encouraging. This workshop will increase my credibility because of my increased confidence, assertiveness and the appropriate approaches I will be using."
"I would highly recommend this lab to other HR Professionals. A large group from one organization would benefit just as greatly from this lab as the cross-section of participants, from different organizations, in the lab I attended. The skills discussed can be put to use immediately upon return to the workplace."
Maximum number of participants: 15 (Register quickly, participation is limited!)
Who: All Human Resource professionals
When: Wednesday, June 10, 2009
Where: Four Points by Sheraton, Milwaukee North, 8900 North Kildeer Court, Brown Deer, WI (convenient suburban location, easily accessible from Hwy 43 and Hwy 41/45)
Time: 8:30am - 4:30pm
Registration fee: $675/person
Two or more for $650/person
(Registration fee includes: Lab, all course materials, lunch and a copy of Joan Lloyd’s CD, How to Coach & Give Feedback That Gets Results)
NONREFUNDABLE REGISTRATION FEE MUST BE PREPAID TO CONFIRM REGISTRATION. DUE TO THE LIMITED NUMBER OF REGISTRATIONS BEING ACCEPTED, PLEASE CALL TODAY TO TAKE ADVANTAGE OF THIS OPPORTUNITY TO TAKE YOUR SKILLS TO A NEW LEVEL.
Call (414) 354-9500 or (800) 348-1944 to register!
This lab is also excellent for small groups from one organization. Call for information about scheduling a private, onsite session for your HR Team.
Joan Lloyd has a solid track record of excellent results. Her firm, Joan Lloyd & Associates, specializes in leadership development, organizational change and teambuilding. This includes executive coaching, 360-degree feedback processes, customized leadership & presentation skills training, team assessment and teambuilding and retreat facilitation. Joan also provides consulting skills training for HR professionals. Clients report results such as: behavior change in leaders, improved team performance and a more committed workforce.
Email Joan at
mailto:info@joanlloyd.com to: submit your question, for consideration for publication, request permission to reprint an article for distribution, or for information about carrying Joan Lloyd's weekly column in your publication, or on your Internet or Intranet site.
© Joan Lloyd & Associates, Inc.